Imposition Of A Copyright Levy In Nigeria: Legal Justifications And Comparative Analysis

Abstract

Copyright owners have the exclusive right to control the reproduction
of their works. Since the advent of recording and copying technology,
reproducing copyright works has become easier. Cases such as Sony Corp of
America v. University City Studios, Inc indicate that copyright owners cannot stop technological advancements since they have both infringing and
non-infringing uses. The reality is that private copying/reproduction is damaging to the right of owners and the entire copyright industry. One of the
ways this situation is addressed is the imposition of copyright/private copying levies in some jurisdictions. Different rationales have been advanced for
the imposition of this levy such as harm/compensation rationale and the
statutory licence rationale. Nigeria is joining other jurisdictions in imposing
this levy as the Copyright Levy Order 2012 was recently signed into law.
This paper discusses the origin and justifications for the imposition of
copyright levies. This practice is examined particularly in the light of the
‘fair dealing for private use’ exception under the Nigerian copyright law
and in other jurisdictions such as the European Union, Germany, United
Kingdom and the United States. It provides a detailed understanding of
‘fair dealing for private use’ and also a justification for the Nigerian Copyright Levy Order under the Nigerian legal system.